On September 11, 2025 Judge Isham granted the Town of Spider Lake motion to dismiss the lawsuit against the town to remove 50 years of Quiet Hours on town lakes. 

In her judgement to dismiss the lawsuit, the judge ruled that the plaintiff ("Boating Club") had not proven harm nor standing their arguments.

Thank you, Town of Spider Lake Supervisors, for working to defend the Northwoods Character of town lakes, and preserve 50 years of the compromise made for the Spider Chain of Lakes, to create both quiet hours and recreational hours for all.